How to Choose a Qualified Intermediary for Your 1031 Exchange
An independent guide to selecting the right QI — what to look for, what to avoid, and the questions you must ask.
What Is a Qualified Intermediary?
A Qualified Intermediary — also called an exchange facilitator, accommodator, or simply a QI — is a third-party professional who facilitates your 1031 exchange by holding the proceeds from the sale of your relinquished property and transferring them to acquire your replacement property. The QI is the critical link in the exchange chain: they ensure you never take constructive receipt of the funds, prepare all required exchange documentation, coordinate with title companies and closing agents, and ensure the exchange complies with IRS requirements under Section 1031 of the Internal Revenue Code and the corresponding Treasury Regulations.
Under the Treasury Regulations, a QI must be someone who is not a “disqualified person.” This means your QI cannot be your attorney, CPA, real estate agent, or employee — or anyone who has served in those roles within the two years preceding the exchange. The rationale is straightforward: the IRS wants an independent third party holding your exchange funds to prevent situations where the taxpayer has easy access to the money, which would break the exchange.
The QI’s role begins before you close on the sale of your relinquished property and ends when the replacement property acquisition closes. For a typical delayed exchange, this means the QI will hold your funds for anywhere from a few weeks to nearly six months. During that time, the QI is responsible for safeguarding what might be your single largest financial asset. For an investor selling a $2,000,000 rental property, that’s $2,000,000 sitting in someone else’s account — which is why choosing the right QI is one of the most consequential decisions in the entire exchange process.
Why You Need a Qualified Intermediary
The fundamental reason you need a QI is the constructive receipt doctrine. Under IRS rules, if you receive the proceeds from the sale of your relinquished property — or if you have the ability to receive them, direct them, or control them — the exchange fails, and you owe capital gains taxes on the entire gain. This isn’t a technicality: it’s the foundation of how 1031 exchanges work.
The Constructive Receipt Rule
If you touch the money — even briefly — the exchange is disqualified. The IRS doesn’t care if you immediately reinvest the funds. The moment you have actual or constructive receipt of the sale proceeds, you have a taxable event. For an investor with $500,000 in capital gains, this mistake could result in a federal tax bill of $100,000 or more (at the 20% long-term capital gains rate), plus 3.8% Net Investment Income Tax ($19,000), plus depreciation recapture at 25%, plus state income taxes.
The QI solves this problem by stepping into the transaction as a middleman. Here’s how it works in practice: when you sell your relinquished property, the closing agent sends the proceeds directly to the QI — you never see or touch the money. The QI holds the funds in a dedicated account while you identify and acquire your replacement property. When you close on the replacement, the QI transfers the funds directly to the closing agent. At no point do the funds pass through your hands or your bank account.
Beyond preventing constructive receipt, your QI also prepares the Exchange Agreement (the contract between you and the QI), the Assignment of Contract documents (which assign your rights in the sale and purchase contracts to the QI), the Notice of Assignment documents (which notify the other parties in the transaction that the contracts have been assigned), and the Identification Notice (the formal document you submit to identify your replacement properties within the 45-day window). Getting any of these documents wrong can jeopardize the exchange — so experience and attention to detail matter enormously.
The Unregulated Industry Problem
Critical Warning
There is no federal licensing requirement for Qualified Intermediaries. Anyone can set up a company and start holding exchange funds tomorrow — with no minimum capital requirements, no mandatory bonding, no required insurance, and no federal regulatory oversight.
This is the single most important fact that most 1031 exchange investors don’t know: the QI industry is largely unregulated. Unlike banks (regulated by the FDIC, OCC, and Federal Reserve), securities brokers (regulated by the SEC and FINRA), or even real estate agents (licensed by state boards), Qualified Intermediaries operate without comprehensive federal oversight.
The consequences of this regulatory gap have been devastating for some investors. In 2008, a major QI firm in the Pacific Northwest, LandAmerica 1031 Exchange Services, filed for bankruptcy, trapping approximately $440 million in client exchange funds. Investors who had trusted this firm — which was a subsidiary of a well-known title insurance company — found themselves unable to complete their exchanges and faced massive tax liabilities. Some investors lost hundreds of thousands of dollars. In another case, a QI in the Southwest was convicted of using client exchange funds to make personal investments, resulting in losses of over $100 million for affected investors.
The Federation of Exchange Accommodators (FEA) is the primary trade association for the QI industry. FEA has advocated for stronger regulation and maintains a code of ethics for its members. However, FEA membership is entirely voluntary, and many QI firms choose not to join. There is no requirement that a QI be an FEA member to operate, and FEA has no enforcement authority over non-members.
Some states have stepped in to fill the regulatory void, passing laws that impose requirements on QIs operating within their borders. These state-level regulations vary widely in scope and stringency, which we cover in detail in the state regulations section below. But in the majority of states, there are no QI-specific regulations at all — which means the burden of due diligence falls entirely on you, the investor.
10 Questions to Ask Before Choosing a QI
Before entrusting your exchange funds to any QI, conduct thorough due diligence. The following ten questions are designed to help you evaluate whether a QI has the financial stability, security measures, experience, and professionalism to safeguard your investment. Don’t accept vague answers — a reputable QI will welcome these questions and provide specific, detailed responses.
How do you secure exchange funds?
This is the single most important question you can ask. Your QI will hold hundreds of thousands — or millions — of dollars of your money. You need to know exactly where those funds will be held, whether the accounts are FDIC insured, and what type of accounts are used. The gold standard is a segregated, FDIC-insured qualified escrow account at a major national bank. Some QIs use money market accounts, which may offer slightly higher interest but carry different risk profiles. Ask whether funds are held in an account in your name or in the QI's name. If the QI deposits your funds into a general operating account, that is an immediate disqualification. For a $1,000,000 exchange, FDIC insurance covers $250,000 per depositor per bank — so ask whether your QI spreads large deposits across multiple banks or uses a CDARS (Certificate of Deposit Account Registry Service) program to maximize FDIC coverage.
What is your fidelity bond and errors & omissions insurance coverage?
A fidelity bond protects you if the QI or its employees steal or misappropriate your funds. Errors and omissions (E&O) insurance protects you if the QI makes a professional mistake — like missing a deadline or filing incorrect documentation — that causes you financial harm. Ask for the dollar amount of coverage on both policies. For a reputable QI handling significant exchange volume, you should expect at least $5 million to $25 million in fidelity bond coverage and $1 million or more in E&O coverage. Ask to see certificates of insurance, not just verbal assurances. If a QI claims they don't need a fidelity bond because they have 'internal controls,' move on to the next candidate.
How long have you been facilitating exchanges?
Experience matters enormously in this industry. A QI who has been facilitating exchanges for 15 or 20 years has seen every type of complication — title issues, last-minute closing changes, identification period emergencies, IRS audits, and more. They know how to handle these situations because they've navigated them before. While there's no magic number, we generally recommend working with a QI that has at least 10 years of continuous exchange facilitation experience. Ask how many exchanges they've completed in total and annually. A well-established QI might handle 1,000 to 5,000 or more exchanges per year. A newer firm handling 50 per year simply hasn't built the institutional knowledge to handle complex situations.
Are you a member of the Federation of Exchange Accommodators (FEA)?
The FEA is the leading trade association for QIs. While membership is voluntary, FEA members agree to adhere to a code of ethics and best practices that include maintaining fidelity bonds, segregating exchange funds, and obtaining regular audits. FEA membership alone doesn't guarantee a great QI, but the absence of membership should raise a question — especially for larger firms that should have the resources and motivation to participate. The FEA also provides continuing education for its members, which helps ensure they stay current on tax law changes and industry best practices.
Do you use segregated or commingled accounts?
In a segregated account, your exchange funds are held in a separate account in your name (or for your benefit). No other client's funds are mixed with yours. In a commingled account, your funds are pooled with other clients' funds in a single account. The critical difference becomes apparent if the QI goes bankrupt: with segregated accounts, your funds are held in trust and should be protected from the QI's creditors. With commingled accounts, your money could become part of the QI's bankruptcy estate, and you might end up as an unsecured creditor waiting months or years — and potentially receiving only pennies on the dollar. For a $750,000 exchange, the difference between segregated and commingled accounts could mean the difference between getting your money back and losing it entirely. Always insist on segregated accounts.
Who has signatory authority over my funds?
You need to know exactly who can authorize the release of your exchange funds. Ideally, the QI should require dual authorization — two separate individuals must approve any disbursement. Ask whether a single employee can wire your funds out. A robust QI will have multiple layers of authorization, including requiring written instructions from you before any funds are released. Some QIs also implement a callback verification system where they will call you at a pre-established phone number to confirm wire instructions before sending funds. This protects against wire fraud, which has become increasingly common in real estate transactions. In 2023, the FBI reported over $145 million in losses from real estate wire fraud.
What happens to my funds if your company goes bankrupt?
This question will tell you a lot about how the QI structures their business. A well-prepared QI will explain that client funds are held in qualified escrow accounts or qualified trust accounts (as defined by Treasury Regulations), which are designed to protect exchange funds from the QI's creditors in the event of bankruptcy. They should be able to point to specific provisions in their exchange agreement that establish these protections. If the QI seems uncomfortable with this question, stumbles through the answer, or cannot clearly articulate the legal protections in place, that's a serious warning sign. The history of the QI industry includes several high-profile bankruptcies where investors lost millions — you want a QI that has learned from those failures and built robust protections.
Can you handle reverse and improvement exchanges?
While most 1031 exchanges are delayed (forward) exchanges, your situation may require a reverse exchange (buying the replacement property before selling the relinquished property) or an improvement exchange (using exchange funds to improve the replacement property). These are significantly more complex transactions that require specialized knowledge, relationships with Exchange Accommodation Titleholders (EATs), and experience with parking arrangements. A QI that can only handle standard forward exchanges may not be the right partner if your needs evolve. Reverse exchanges typically cost $5,000 to $10,000 or more, and improvement exchanges can be even more expensive — so you want a QI with demonstrated experience in these areas. Ask how many reverse and improvement exchanges they've facilitated in the past year.
What are your fees and what's included?
QI fees vary significantly, and the lowest price is rarely the best value. A typical forward (delayed) exchange costs between $750 and $1,500, though some high-volume national firms may charge slightly less. This fee should include preparation of all exchange documents, holding your funds in a segregated account, coordination with title companies and closing agents, the identification notice process, and disbursement of funds at closing. Ask specifically about additional charges: wire fees (typically $25 to $35 per wire), assignment and notice fees, additional property fees if you're buying multiple replacement properties, and interest earned on your funds (some QIs keep this, others pass it through). For a reverse exchange, expect fees of $5,000 to $10,000, and for an improvement exchange, fees can range from $5,000 to $15,000 or more depending on complexity.
Will I have a dedicated exchange officer?
A 1031 exchange involves multiple deadlines, coordination with numerous parties (title companies, closing agents, real estate brokers, attorneys), and potential complications that require quick responses. You need a single point of contact — a dedicated exchange officer — who knows your file, understands your specific situation, and can respond promptly when issues arise. Ask whether you'll be assigned a specific officer or whether your file will be handled by whoever is available. Ask about response times — during the 45-day identification period, you may need answers within hours, not days. A good QI will assign you a named exchange officer, provide direct contact information, and commit to specific response time standards. Some larger QIs also provide online portals where you can track your exchange status, view documents, and submit identification notices electronically.
Red Flags to Watch For
During your QI selection process, watch for these warning signs that suggest a QI may not adequately protect your exchange funds. Any one of these red flags should give you serious pause; multiple red flags should send you looking elsewhere.
- Below-market fees with no clear explanation — if a QI charges $300 for a forward exchange when the industry average is $750 to $1,500, ask yourself how they're staying in business. They may be cutting corners on insurance, using commingled accounts, or relying on interest income from your funds as their primary revenue source.
- High-pressure sales tactics or urgency to sign immediately — a reputable QI will give you time to review their exchange agreement, compare options, and ask questions. If they're pushing you to commit before you've had time to do due diligence, walk away.
- No fidelity bond or refusal to provide proof of insurance — this is a non-negotiable requirement. Any QI that operates without a fidelity bond is putting your funds at unnecessary risk.
- Commingled funds without adequate protections — if the QI pools your money with other clients' funds and cannot clearly explain the legal protections in place, find another QI.
- New companies with no track record — while everyone has to start somewhere, your 1031 exchange is not the place to take chances on an unproven firm. A company with less than 5 years of experience and limited exchange volume presents higher risk than an established firm.
- Unwillingness to share financial information or audit reports — a transparent QI will willingly provide information about their financial stability, bonding, and insurance coverage. Evasiveness on these topics is a serious red flag.
- No qualified escrow or trust agreement — the exchange agreement should clearly establish that your funds will be held in a qualified escrow account or qualified trust account as defined by Treasury Regulations Section 1.1031(k)-1(g)(3). If this language is absent, your funds may not be protected.
- The QI is also acting as your real estate broker or agent — while not necessarily disqualifying, be cautious when the same company handling your exchange funds also stands to earn a commission on the property sale or purchase. This creates a potential conflict of interest.
How QI Fees Work
Understanding QI fee structures helps you compare options on an apples-to-apples basis and avoid surprises at closing. QI fees vary by exchange type, complexity, and the specific firm, but here are the typical ranges you should expect:
Forward (Delayed) Exchange
$750 – $1,500
Most common exchange type. Includes exchange documents, fund holding, identification processing, and closing coordination.
Reverse Exchange
$5,000 – $10,000
Requires Exchange Accommodation Titleholder (EAT) to hold title. Higher fees reflect greater complexity and liability.
Improvement Exchange
$5,000 – $15,000
Involves construction management coordination and ongoing fund disbursements during the improvement period.
Additional Property Fee
$250 – $500
Per additional replacement property beyond the first. Covers extra documentation and closing coordination.
Beyond the base fee, ask about wire transfer fees ($25 to $35 per wire is typical), interest earned on your exchange funds (some QIs keep all interest, others credit a portion back to you), cancellation fees if the exchange doesn’t complete, and any additional charges for complex situations. Some QIs charge extra for same-day wires, weekend or holiday closings, or expedited document preparation.
A critical point about interest: when interest rates are elevated, the interest earned on exchange funds can be substantial. On a $1,500,000 exchange held for 120 days at a 4.5% annual rate, the interest earned would be approximately $22,200. Some QIs keep this interest as additional revenue, while others pass it through to the client. Ask upfront how interest is handled — it could significantly affect the true cost of the exchange.
Fund Security: The Most Important Factor
If you take only one thing from this guide, let it be this: the security of your exchange funds is the most important factor in choosing a QI. Everything else — fees, convenience, customer service — is secondary to knowing that your money will be there when you need it to complete your exchange.
The QI industry has experienced several high-profile failures that resulted in devastating losses for investors. The LandAmerica 1031 Exchange Services bankruptcy in 2008 is the most well-known, trapping approximately $440 million in client exchange funds. But it’s not the only case. Southwest Exchange, a QI based in Arizona, collapsed in 2009 after its principal was found to have used client funds for unauthorized investments, resulting in losses exceeding $100 million. In 2013, a Colorado-based QI was charged with fraud after misappropriating millions in client exchange funds.
These failures share common characteristics: commingled funds, insufficient bonding, inadequate oversight, and a lack of regulatory protections. In each case, investors who had done everything right — sold their property, engaged a QI, identified replacement property — found themselves unable to complete their exchanges through no fault of their own. Many faced tax bills of hundreds of thousands of dollars on top of lost exchange funds.
Fund Security Checklist
- Segregated accounts — your funds are held separately from all other clients’ funds
- FDIC insured accounts at a major national bank
- Qualified escrow account or qualified trust account per Treasury Regulations
- Fidelity bond of at least $5 million to $25 million
- Errors & omissions insurance of at least $1 million
- Dual authorization required for all fund disbursements
- Independent audits of exchange fund accounts at least annually
When you’re evaluating a QI, don’t just take their word for it. Ask for proof: certificates of insurance for fidelity bonds and E&O coverage, the name and branch of the bank where your funds will be held, a copy of the exchange agreement showing the qualified escrow or trust language, and the name of their auditing firm. A QI that hesitates to provide this information is not a QI you should trust with your exchange funds.
State-Specific QI Regulations
While there are no comprehensive federal regulations governing QIs, several states have enacted their own laws to protect investors. If you’re conducting an exchange in one of these states, your QI must comply with additional requirements. If your state isn’t on this list, that means there are fewer protections in place — making your own due diligence even more critical.
California
Requires QIs to maintain a fidelity bond of at least $1 million and errors and omissions insurance. QIs must place exchange funds in a segregated account or provide a surety bond. The law also requires specific disclosures to clients about the risks of exchange transactions.
Colorado
Enacted QI regulations following the collapse of a local QI firm. Requires QIs to maintain fidelity bonds, segregate exchange funds, and register with the state. Colorado law also mandates specific disclosures about fund security measures.
Connecticut
Requires QIs to register and maintain minimum levels of fidelity bond coverage. Exchange funds must be deposited in qualified escrow or trust accounts. QIs must provide written disclosures about their fund security practices.
Idaho
Imposes licensing and bonding requirements on QIs operating in the state. Requires segregated exchange fund accounts and regular financial reporting.
Maine
Requires QIs to maintain fidelity bonds and errors and omissions insurance. Exchange funds must be held in segregated accounts. The law includes specific consumer protection provisions for exchange clients.
Nevada
Requires QIs to obtain a license, maintain a fidelity bond of at least $1 million, and provide annual audited financial statements. Exchange funds must be held in segregated, FDIC-insured accounts. Nevada law also prohibits QIs from using exchange funds for their own investment purposes.
Oregon
One of the earliest states to regulate QIs. Requires licensing, bonding, and segregated exchange fund accounts. Oregon law also mandates that QIs carry errors and omissions insurance and submit to regular examinations.
Virginia
Requires QIs to register with the state and maintain minimum levels of fidelity bond coverage. Exchange funds must be held in qualified escrow or trust accounts at FDIC-insured institutions.
Washington
One of the most comprehensive QI regulatory frameworks in the country, enacted following the LandAmerica bankruptcy. Requires QI licensing, minimum capital requirements, fidelity bonds of at least $1 million, segregated exchange fund accounts, annual audits, and detailed reporting to the Washington Department of Financial Institutions. Washington also requires QIs to maintain a surety bond or letter of credit.
Even if your state does not have QI-specific regulations, the standards established by states like Washington, Nevada, and Oregon represent best practices that any reputable QI should meet voluntarily. Use these regulatory benchmarks as your minimum expectations regardless of where you live.
FEA Membership and What It Means
The Federation of Exchange Accommodators (FEA) is the national trade association representing Qualified Intermediaries and other professionals involved in 1031 exchanges. Founded in 1988, the FEA promotes ethical business practices, provides continuing education, and advocates for legislation and regulation that protects exchange investors.
FEA members agree to abide by a Code of Ethics that includes commitments to maintain adequate fidelity bond coverage, hold exchange funds in segregated accounts, carry errors and omissions insurance, and operate with transparency and integrity. The FEA also offers a Certified Exchange Specialist (CES) designation to individuals who demonstrate proficiency in exchange facilitation through examination and continuing education.
However, it’s important to understand the limitations of FEA membership. FEA is a voluntary trade association — it is not a regulatory body. It cannot compel non-members to follow its guidelines, and its enforcement authority over members is limited. FEA membership is a positive indicator, but it is not a guarantee of financial stability, competence, or integrity. You should still conduct independent due diligence even when working with an FEA member.
That said, FEA membership signals that a QI is invested in the profession, committed to staying current on industry developments, and willing to adhere to a set of ethical standards. All else being equal, an FEA member QI with a CES-designated exchange officer is preferable to a non-member firm. The FEA website maintains a directory of member firms that you can use as a starting point for your QI search.
Our Recommendation
After reviewing hundreds of exchanges and working with investors across the country, here is what we recommend when selecting a Qualified Intermediary:
- Choose a QI with at least 10 years of continuous exchange facilitation experience and a track record of handling at least 500 exchanges per year
- Require segregated, FDIC-insured accounts at a major national bank — no exceptions
- Verify fidelity bond coverage of at least $10 million and errors & omissions coverage of at least $1 million
- Confirm FEA membership and ask whether your exchange officer holds the CES designation
- Review the exchange agreement carefully — look for qualified escrow or trust account language, dual authorization requirements, and clear provisions protecting your funds in the event of the QI's insolvency
- Ask for references from attorneys, CPAs, or real estate professionals who have worked with the QI on previous exchanges
- Get a complete fee schedule in writing before committing — including wire fees, interest policies, and charges for additional replacement properties
- Ensure you will have a dedicated exchange officer with direct contact information and defined response time standards
Your Qualified Intermediary will hold your exchange funds for months. They’ll handle the documentation that determines whether your exchange succeeds or fails. Choosing a QI is not the place to shop for the lowest price — it’s the place to invest in security, experience, and reliability. A $500 savings on QI fees means nothing if it puts a $500,000 exchange at risk.
Related Resources
Need Help Finding a Qualified Intermediary?
Our exchange specialists can help you evaluate QIs, ask the right questions, and ensure your exchange funds are properly protected. There’s no cost or obligation.
Talk to Our Exchange Specialists